History of Quanzhou and Zhangzhou

AI-rendered sepia photograph depicting the city of Zhangzhou

Question

Please describe the history of the port city of Quanzhou in Fujian, China. Did it exist at the same time as Zhangzhou? Were they competing ports? Was one more significant than the other at different points in history?

Answer

Quanzhou, located in Fujian Province, China, has a rich and storied history as one of China's most prominent port cities, especially during the medieval period. The development of Quanzhou and nearby Zhangzhou followed intertwined but distinct trajectories, often influenced by their respective geographic locations, trade connections, and political circumstances.

Early History and Development of Quanzhou

Quanzhou's origins as a port city trace back to the Tang dynasty (618-907 CE), but it rose to prominence during the Song dynasty (960-1279 CE) and Yuan dynasty (1271-1368 CE). Quanzhou became one of the world's busiest seaports during the 10th to 14th centuries, known to traders from Arabia, India, Persia, and Southeast Asia. It was sometimes referred to as the "City of Light" or "Zayton" (by Arab traders), and Marco Polo famously praised it as one of the largest and most prosperous ports in the world.

At its peak, Quanzhou was a global hub in the Maritime Silk Road, facilitating the exchange of goods such as silk, ceramics, spices, and precious stones. Its cosmopolitan character was marked by the presence of various religious communities, including Muslims, Hindus, Christians, and Buddhists, as evidenced by historical structures like the Qingjing Mosque and Kaiyuan Temple. The city had a robust shipbuilding industry and a significant presence of foreign traders who set up shop there.

Quanzhou's importance declined during the Ming dynasty (1368-1644), as the Ming rulers imposed stricter maritime trade restrictions and piracy became a problem. Eventually, other ports like Guangzhou (Canton) gained prominence, while Quanzhou's trade activities diminished, though it remained a regional center.

Zhangzhou's Development

Zhangzhou, another major city in Fujian, also developed into an important port, but its rise was more gradual and was often overshadowed by Quanzhou during the Song and Yuan periods. Zhangzhou is located further inland, along the Jiulong River, and its harbor facilities were not as extensive as Quanzhou's during the earlier periods of maritime trade. However, during the late Ming and early Qing dynasties, Zhangzhou began to play a more significant role in trade due to changes in the maritime landscape.

Zhangzhou's rise came partly because of its proximity to Taiwan and the growing trade networks in the South China Sea. During the Ming and Qing periods, it became a major exporter of agricultural products, including sugar and rice, and its merchants engaged in trade with Southeast Asia, particularly with regions like the Philippines and Indonesia.

Comparison and Competition

While both cities were important to Fujian's maritime economy, Quanzhou and Zhangzhou did not directly compete with each other in the way that modern commercial ports might. Instead, their roles evolved based on changing political, economic, and geographic factors.

Quanzhou: During its peak in the Song and Yuan dynasties, Quanzhou was by far the more significant port due to its coastal location, expansive harbor, and deep integration with global trade. Quanzhou was a true international port and one of the most important cities on the Maritime Silk Road.
Zhangzhou: Zhangzhou's significance grew in later periods, particularly during the late Ming and early Qing dynasties, as China's trade policy shifted and regional trade patterns evolved. By the late Ming, Zhangzhou had become a key point of departure for Chinese migrants to Southeast Asia and Taiwan. Zhangzhou's rise in importance came at a time when Quanzhou's fortunes were in decline due to changing policies on foreign trade and internal strife, such as piracy and the coastal evacuation policies under the Qing.

Shifts in Importance

Song and Yuan Dynasties: Quanzhou was the dominant port, while Zhangzhou played a secondary role.
Late Ming and Early Qing Dynasties: Quanzhou's importance declined, while Zhangzhou, because of its connections with Taiwan and Southeast Asia, grew in significance.

Both Quanzhou and Zhangzhou played significant roles in Fujian's maritime history, but they were not direct competitors for the same period of time. Quanzhou was the larger, more internationally renowned port during the Song and Yuan dynasties, while Zhangzhou gained greater significance in the Ming and Qing eras, particularly with the rise of regional trade in Southeast Asia and Taiwan. The two cities complemented rather than competed with each other, contributing to Fujian's long-standing role in maritime trade.

Did Quanzhou rise in significance earlier in history compared to Guangzhou?

Yes, Quanzhou rose in significance as an international port earlier than Guangzhou (Canton), although both cities eventually became important centers of maritime trade. Their historical trajectories, however, were shaped by different factors and time periods.

Quanzhou's Earlier Rise

Quanzhou's rise to prominence as a port began during the Tang dynasty (618-907 CE), but it reached its zenith during the Song dynasty (960-1279 CE) and continued into the Yuan dynasty (1271-1368 CE). During these periods, Quanzhou was one of the largest and busiest ports in the world, functioning as a key hub in the Maritime Silk Road. It attracted traders from Arabia, India, Persia, and Southeast Asia, dealing in goods like silk, ceramics, spices, and other luxury items.

Several factors contributed to Quanzhou's early prominence:

Strategic location: Quanzhou's coastal position in southeastern China made it an ideal gateway for maritime trade, especially with Southeast Asia, the Indian Ocean, and beyond.
Song and Yuan dynasties' support for trade: Both dynasties actively promoted overseas trade, issuing favorable policies for merchants, encouraging shipbuilding, and developing port infrastructure in Quanzhou.
Cosmopolitan culture: Quanzhou was a melting pot of different cultures and religions, as seen in its many historical sites, such as the Qingjing Mosque (built in 1009 CE) and its diverse foreign communities.

Quanzhou was so significant during this period that it was widely known by foreign traders as "Zayton" and was praised by travelers like Marco Polo. However, after the fall of the Yuan dynasty and the beginning of the Ming dynasty (1368-1644), Quanzhou's prominence began to decline due to restrictive maritime policies (like the Haijin, or sea ban) and the rise of piracy.

Guangzhou's Later Prominence

In contrast, Guangzhou rose to global prominence somewhat later, although it had already been a notable trading port since ancient times. Its peak came during the Ming (1368-1644) and Qing (1644-1912) dynasties.

Guangzhou's earlier history can be traced back to the Han dynasty (202 BCE-220 CE), when it was known as a regional trade hub, but it did not become a major international port until later. Its rise in global significance was particularly marked during the Ming and Qing dynasties due to several factors:

The Canton System: In 1757, the Qing dynasty established the "Canton System," which restricted all foreign trade to the port of Guangzhou. This made Guangzhou the exclusive gateway for Western trade, especially with European countries. As a result, it became a focal point for international commerce, particularly in tea, silk, porcelain, and opium.
Strategic location near Southeast Asia: Guangzhou's proximity to the South China Sea made it an important port for trade with Southeast Asia and, eventually, European powers like the Portuguese, Dutch, and British.
Foreign trade communities: By the 18th century, Guangzhou had a flourishing foreign trade enclave, where Western merchants operated under strict Chinese supervision.

Guangzhou's significance continued to grow into the 19th century, especially as it became a major site of conflict during the Opium Wars (1839-1842 and 1856-1860), when foreign powers pushed to open China to more trade.

Comparison of Timing

Quanzhou's earlier rise: Quanzhou was at its peak of significance as a global trading port during the Song and Yuan dynasties (10th-14th centuries), long before Guangzhou rose to international prominence.
Guangzhou's later dominance: Although Guangzhou was an active trading port for centuries, its role as China's dominant international trading city came later, especially after the establishment of the Canton System in the mid-18th century, which restricted all foreign trade to Guangzhou.

Quanzhou rose to prominence earlier in history, particularly during the Song and Yuan dynasties, while Guangzhou's most significant rise as an international trading port came later, especially during the Qing dynasty. Quanzhou's importance in global trade diminished after the Yuan dynasty, while Guangzhou came to dominate China's maritime trade with the West in the 18th and 19th centuries. Both cities played crucial roles in different periods of China's maritime history, but Quanzhou's early prominence preceded Guangzhou's later global role.

Latest updates on Penang Travel Tips

About this website

Thanks for reading this page. My name is Timothy Tye. My hobby is to research information about places, and share the information with people on this website. I started this website on 5 January 2003, and since then, have written about over 20,000 places, mostly in Malaysia and Singapore.

Please use the information on this page as guidance only. While I try my best to provide you information that is as accurate as I can get it to be, I do apologize for any errors. Also, as I might not be able to update some information on time, some of these pages may contain outdated information.

Terms & Condition of Use | Privacy Policy